Abstract
Background and Objectives To analyze the frequencies of major genetic variants and the clinical features in Finnish patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) with or without the C9orf72 hexanucleotide repeat expansion.
Methods A cohort of patients with motor neuron disease was recruited between 1993 and 2020 at the Helsinki University Hospital and 2 second-degree outpatient clinics in Helsinki. Finnish ancestry patients with ALS fulfilled the diagnosis according to the revised El Escorial criteria and the Awaji-criteria. Two categories of familial ALS (FALS) were used. A patient was defined FALS-A if at least 1 first- or second-degree family member had ALS, and FALS-NP, if family members had additional neurologic or psychiatric endophenotypes.
Results Of the 815 patients, 25% had FALS-A and 45% FALS-NP. C9orf72 expansion (C9pos) was found in 256 (31%) of all patients, in 58% of FALS-A category, in 48% of FALS-NP category, and in 23 or 17% of sporadic cases using the FALS-A or FALS-NP definition. C9pos or SOD1 p.D91A homozygosity was found in 328 (40%) of the 815 patients. We compared demographic and clinical characteristics between C9pos and patients with unknown cause of ALS (Unk). We found that the age at onset was significantly earlier and survival markedly shorter in the C9pos vs Unk patients with ALS. The shortest survival was found in bulbar-onset male C9pos patients, whereas the longest survival was found in Unk limb-onset males. Older age at onset associated consistently with shorter survival in C9pos and Unk patients in both limb-onset and bulbar-onset groups. There were no significant differences in the frequencies of bulbar-onset and limb-onset patients in C9pos and Unk groups. ALS-frontotemporal dementia (FTD) was more common in C9pos (17%) than in Unk (4%) patients, and of all patients with ALS-FTD, 70% were C9pos.
Discussion These results provide further evidence for the short survival of C9orf72-associated ALS. A prominent role of the C9orf72 and SOD1 variants was found in the Finnish population. An unusually high frequency of C9pos was also found among patients with sporadic ALS. The enrichment of these 2 variants likely contributes to the high incidence of ALS in Finland.
Glossary
- ALS=
- amyotrophic lateral sclerosis;
- AUC=
- area under the curve;
- FALS=
- familial ALS;
- FTD=
- frontotemporal dementia;
- GWAS=
- genome-wide association study;
- MST=
- mean survival time;
- OR=
- odds ratio;
- SALS=
- sporadic ALS
Introduction
The most common genetic cause of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) in European populations is the hexanucleotide repeat expansion in the C9orf72 gene.1,2 In these populations, up to 50% of patients with familial ALS (FALS) and about 5% of patients with sporadic ALS (SALS) carry this expansion (C9pos).3 The variant is much less common among Asian populations.4
Frontotemporal dementia (FTD) is another common phenotype associated with the C9orf72 expansion; it accounts for about 25% of familial FTD in Europeans3 and up to 86% of familial patients having both FTD and ALS. The C9pos patients may rarely have other clinical presentations than ALS or FTD such as movement disorders, psychiatric symptoms, and idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus.5,6 A younger than average age at onset and shorter survival have been relatively uniformly reported among the C9pos patients with ALS, although the penetrance of this expansion is variable.7 A higher proportion of bulbar onset has been inconsistently reported.8,–,16
Finland is among the countries with the highest incidence of ALS in the world.17,–,19 We aimed to study the frequencies of the major genetic variants and compare the clinical features of ALS in Finnish patients with the C9orf72 expansion (C9pos) and in patients with unknown cause of ALS (Unk).
Methods
Study Design and Participants
Between 1993 and 2020, we recruited 836 patients with motor neuron disease attending the Neurology Department at the Helsinki University Hospital or 2 private neurology outpatient clinics in Helsinki. The clinics serve the population of the Helsinki and Uusimaa health care district (population size 1,634,319 on December 31, 2016). These units also received referrals from other parts of the country. We excluded patients where both parents were of non-Finnish descent (n = 15), patients with spinal and bulbar muscular atrophy variant in androgen receptor gene20 (n = 2), and patients with Jokela-type spinal muscular atrophy variant in the CHCHD10 gene21 (n = 4). Of the remaining 815 patients, 74% lived in the province of Uusimaa in southern Finland. eFigure 1 (links.lww.com/NXG/A517) illustrates the geographic distribution of the patients and the frequencies of the C9orf72 and SOD1 variants in Uusimaa and other regions. Four hundred five patients were included in the discovery study of the C9orf72 expansion1 and a subsequent population frequency analysis of the expansion.3 We excluded homozygotes for SOD1 p.D91A and heterozygotes for SOD1 p.A90V from the clinical data analysis of the present study because patients with these variants differ from classical ALS.22,23 The details of the patients with the SOD1 p.A90V variant have been previously reported.23 We also excluded patients with respiratory onset and patients with incomplete clinical data. The final statistical analysis for phenotypic comparisons included 707 patients with ALS (Figure 1).
ALS = amyotrophic lateral sclerosis; C9pos = carrier of the hexanucleotide repeat expansion in the C9orf72 gene; FALS-A = familial ALS, only first- and second-degree relatives with ALS (A) were considered in the definition of FALS; FTD = frontotemporal dementia; SALS-A = sporadic ALS; SBMA = spinobulbar muscular atrophy; SMAJ = spinal muscular atrophy Jokela type; Unk = noncarrier. SALS-NP/FALS-NP = broad definition, first- and second-degree relatives with various neurologic and psychiatric (NP) disorders were included in FALS-NP. FALS-A was classified in 158 families, C9pos in 91 (58%), Unk in 41 (26%), and SOD1 p.D91A in 26 (16%) families. FALS-NP was classified in in 326 families, of which 167 (51%) families were C9pos, 126 (39%) Unk, and 33 (10%) SOD1 p.D91A. Respiratory-onset cases were considered outliers in survival and were excluded from the phenotype analysis. FALS-NP categorization included the following neurologic disorders: ALS, FTD, Alzheimer disease, Lewy body disease, other dementia or cognitive deficit not linked to vascular or traumatic etiology, Parkinson disease, and Huntington disease. Neurodegenerative conditions such as corticobasal degeneration and multiple system atrophy as well as disorders causing muscular weakness or stiffness such as polyneuropathies, myasthenia gravis, myasthenic syndromes, and Stiff-person syndrome were grouped. We did not include mild cognitive deficits, unspecified memory problems, tremors, ataxias, seizures, epilepsies, stroke, severe trauma, post-polio syndrome, multiple sclerosis, migraine, congenital disorders, metastases, primary tumors of the nervous system, anecdotal recollections of autism-type disorders, and very late-onset dementias, i.e., when the relative was known or suspected to develop dementia at age 80 years or over. FALS-NP categorization included the following psychiatric conditions: schizophrenia, psychosis, delusions, bipolar disorder, significant alcohol or narcotics abuse/dependence, and suicide. Mood disorders were grouped (anxiety and depression when severe and diagnosed before the index patient was diagnosed with ALS). We did not include anecdotal mental problems, character disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder, unspecified apathy, and recital faux pas.
Diagnosis
Patients were assessed by H.L. and at least 1 other neurologist. The patients fulfilled the criteria of definite or probable ALS according to the El Escorial criteria,24 and from 2001 onward, according to the revised version. From 2008, the Awaji-criteria (electroneuromyography, ENMG) were combined to the clinical criteria. The last day of follow-up was June 21, 2021.
Clinical Variables and Familiality
Data on the age at onset, age at death, duration of disease, site of onset, sex, family history, and comorbid neurodegenerative and psychiatric diseases were gathered by interview and from the patients' charts and death certificates. Death certificates were obtained from Official Statistics of Finland.25 The date of death was confirmed from the Digital and Population Data Services Agency of Finland using a unique personal id-code available at reference 26, ensuring that no patients were lost to follow-up. The age at symptom onset was defined as the age at which the patient first experienced motor dysfunction that led to the ALS diagnosis. The disease duration was defined as the number of years starting from the year of onset to the year of death or mechanical ventilation required for more than 12 hours per day.
In C9pos ALS families, an increased frequency of neurologic and psychiatric disorders has been reported.27,28 We used 2 definitions of FALS. A patient was defined as FALS-A if at least 1 first- or second-degree family member had ALS and FALS-NP if 1 or more first- or second-degree family member had neurologic or psychiatric entities as confirmed from the index patient's chart, interview, or from relatives' hospital records, or death certificate in equivocal cases. The family history interview was conducted by H.L. and the information came from the patient and family members. Systematic questionnaires were not used. Our FALS-NP category (described in Figure 1) had slightly broader criteria than the definite and probable categories proposed by Byrne,29 but for FALS-A, we did not count in family members with pure FTD without evidence of motor symptoms. ALS patients' comorbid disorders were coded as present or absent if they had been observed during the course of ALS. FTD was coded separately from other dementias and cognitive deficits. Comorbid cognitive deficit was a widely defined variable, which includes Alzheimer disease and other dementias or cognitive deficits not linked to vascular or traumatic etiology. Riluzole, lithium, and gabapentin were used by some patients during the study period, but because the dose and length of use varied, we did not include these treatments in survival analysis.
Standard Protocol Approvals, Registrations, and Patient Consents
The study protocol was approved by the Institutional Review Boards at the Haaga Neuro Clinic (December 10, 1993) and the Helsinki University Hospital (Drno 299/E9/2001, Drno 401/13/03/01/2009, HUS/1720/2019). Written informed consent was obtained from each patient or a close relative, depending on whether the patient was physically able to give a written consent.
Genotyping
DNA was extracted using standard methods from peripheral blood leukocytes. The C9orf72 repeat expansion was newly genotyped in 2019–2020 in all samples with DNA available (796 of the 815). We assessed the C9orf72 hexanucleotide repeat expansion as previously described; samples with more than 45 repeats and the typical sawtooth pattern in repeat-primed PCR, which only produced the smaller amplicon in over-the-repeat PCR, were categorized as expansions.30 In 2 patients, the expansion status was based on the discovery study,1 and in 17, it was based on clinical genetic diagnostics at the University of Turku or University of Tampere, Finland. Seven patients had 2 copies of the C9orf72 intermediate-length alleles and a genotype (7–45/17–45 repeats), which is a risk factor for ALS.31 Six of these patients were included in the Unk group. One was SOD1 p.D91A homozygote and was excluded from phenotype analysis. The SOD1 p.D91A variant was verified as a diagnostic service in 72 samples at the University of Turku, Finland, and 799 samples were also screened for this variant using genome-wide association study (GWAS) data that allowed reliable calling or imputation of the SOD1 p.D91A variant. Of these, 772 samples were genotyped by FinnGen ThermoFisher Axiom custom array v2 (finngen.fi/fi/node/59) and 27 samples as described.32 The SOD1 p.D91A genotype was missing in 16 patients, but none of these had a clinical course compatible with this subtype of ALS. CHCHD10 p.G66V variant rs730880031 was screened in 772 samples using the FinnGen array, but none of the patients had this variant. The SOD1 p.A90V was discovered in 1 patient along with neuropathologic and exome-wide analysis and in 6 patients by the imputation of this variant in the 772 genotyped patients (rs1280042397, IMPUTE2 INFO score 1.0 indicating reliable imputation) and confirmed by sequencing. We assessed possible cryptic relatedness in the patients with ALS using the GWAS data using a threshold of >0.185 proportion identity by descent between 2 patients to define relatedness.
Statistical Analysis
Survival, age at onset, and age at end point were expressed in years. Univariate comparisons were made with the Mann-Whitney U test. We used binary logistic regression to analyze which phenotypes were associated with C9pos or Unk status. Cox proportional hazards models were built to analyze the hazard ratios associated with clinical variables. The Efron likelihood was used for estimation, coding of factors was sigma restricted, and models included all effects. The proportionality assumption was tested for all factors using Schoenfeld residual plots. We added an interaction term familiality × genotype on the assumption that familial C9pos patients might have a disproportionately severe presentation. Both complete and censored cases were included in the mean survival time (MST) analysis33,34 and were expressed in years and calculated as the area under the curve (AUC) of a Kaplan-Meier curve. The AUC can be viewed as the definite integral of a curve that describes variation with time. For this calculation, we smoothed the survival data by adding a 2-decimal random number between −0.5 and 0.5. The same jittered data are used in figures for clarity. For MST, data from living (66/707) patients were excluded from analysis.33,34 Statistical analysis was performed using Statistica version 13.3 software (StatSoft, Inc., 2013). AUC was calculated in Microsoft Excel using the trapezoidal rule.
Data Availability
Anonymized data not published within this article will be made available by request to a qualified investigator with institutional review and approval.
Results
Frequencies of the C9orf72 and SOD1 Variant Carriers
We identified 815 Finnish patients with ALS over the 27-year study period. Of these, 256 patients (31%) carried the C9orf72 repeat expansion (C9pos), 79 (9.7%) had a SOD1 variant, and 480 (59%) had an unknown cause of ALS (Unk) (Figure 1). Overall, the 2 most common variants C9orf72 or SOD1p.D91A homozygosity were found in 328 (40%) of the patients.
Familiality
We used 2 definitions of FALS (see Methods: Clinical variables and familiality). Using the FALS-A definition, 203 (25%) of all patients were familial and were distributed in 158 unique families: 91 families were C9pos (58%), 41 families Unk (26%), and 26 families had SOD1 p.D91A (16%). Using the broader FALS-NP definition, 369 (45%) of all patients were familial. These were distributed in 326 unique families, of which 167 (51%) were C9pos, 126 (39%) were Unk, and 33 (10%) had SOD1 p.D91A. The distribution of the neurologic and psychiatric endophenotypes among relatives of C9pos and Unk FALS-NP cases is shown in eFigure 2A and eFigure 2B (links.lww.com/NXG/A517).
Demographics and Clinical Features of Patients With ALS With and Without the C9orf72 Expansion
Here, we focus on the characteristics of the C9pos and Unk patients with ALS. Patients with SOD1 variants, respiratory-onset disease (outliers in survival), or incomplete clinical data were removed from the subsequent analysis, as shown in Figure 1. Familiality was categorized only as FALS-A in this analysis.
Table 1 shows the demographic and clinical characteristics of the C9pos and Unk patients with ALS. The median age at onset in the C9pos and Unk patients with ALS was 58.0 and 61.0 years, respectively (Mann-Whitney U Z = 3.6025, p = 0.0003). The observed age at onset varied according to the site of onset and sex (eTable 1, links.lww.com/NXG/A517). The most pronounced effect was found in ALS Unk limb-onset vs bulbar-onset patients; the median age at onsets were 57 vs 66 years (p = 4.6 × 10−12). Limb-onset patients had slightly, but significantly, earlier age at onset also in the C9pos group (p = 0.048), and males had earlier age at onset in the Unk group (p = 0.018). The median survival was 2.0 years (0.5–13.0) in the C9pos vs 3.0 years (0.5–26.0) in the Unk group (Mann-Whitney U −3.6021, p = 0.0003). We did not find any significant differences in the demographic or clinical features in comparisons between C9pos FALS-A and SALS-A. However, among the Unk group, the patients with FALS-A had a significantly lower age at onset than SALS-A (Table 1). ALS-FTD was significantly more common in the C9pos (17%) than in the Unk (4%) group (Fisher exact test p = 2.27 × 10−8). ALS-FTD with bulbar onset was slightly more common than bulbar onset in pure ALS (46% vs 36%), but the difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.13).
Demographic and Clinical Characteristics of the Patients According to the Carriership of the C9orf72 Hexanucleotide Expansion (C9pos/Unk)
The distribution of the age at onset and survival in the C9pos and Unk patients is shown in Figure 2. These data demonstrate that the age at onset modulates survival more in the Unk than in the C9pos patients. As expected, the Unk group is more heterogeneous in survival and age at onset distributions. The C9pos group was relatively homogeneous and did not include many outliers in either survival or age at onset; there were only 5 patients (2%) with survival longer than 8 years, and only 16 (6%) patients had an age at onset outside the age band 40–70 years (Figure 2). The cumulative incidence by age of C9pos ALS in males/females, bulbar-/limb-onset, and SALS-A/FALS-A dichotomies is shown in eFigure 3 (links.lww.com/NXG/A517).
The regression line between age at onset and survival is given in red.
Association of Clinical Variables With C9pos ALS
We analyzed features that differentiate C9pos from Unk ALS using binary logistic regression. We found a significant association of C9pos with FALS-A, earlier age at onset, and shorter survival (Table 2). The effect size33 was large in survival (odds ratio [OR] 10.7–14.4) and FALS-A (OR 8.9) and medium for the age at onset (OR 5.3–5.4). The site of onset was not associated with C9 status.
Association of Variables With C9pos ALS Using Binary Logistic Regression
Effects of the Expansion, Age at Onset, Site of Onset, Sex, and MST
Next, we analyzed features modulating survival. Figure 3 shows the MST of C9pos and Unk patients grouped by age at onset, site of onset, and sex. First, the MST of the C9pos patients was shorter than the cohort's average, regardless of whether the onset site was bulbar or in the limbs. Second, bulbar-onset Unk patients had almost equally short survival as C9pos patients, whereas limb-onset Unk patients survived longer than the cohort on average. Third, the MST was slightly longer in females than males with bulbar onset, whereas the opposite was found in limb-onset patients. Fourth, the age at onset had a clear impact on the patient's survival. In all groups, there was a progressive shortening in the MST with later age at onset.
The dotted vertical line indicates the mean value of all groups. ALS = amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.
Cox Regression Hazard Ratios for Death
Using a Cox proportional hazard model of the whole cohort, we found that the genotype C9pos, bulbar onset, and late age at onset statistically significantly increased the risk of death by a factor of 1.5–2.0 (Table 3). FALS-A and sex did not have a significant effect on survival.
Hazard Ratios for Death in Cox Proportional Hazards Regression Analysis
C9orf72 Intermediate-Length Alleles in C9pos Patients
We have previously provided evidence that the carriership of 2 copies of the intermediate-length alleles (7–45 repeats) increases the risk of ALS when the longer allele is ≥17 repeats.31 Therefore, we tested whether the carriership of an intermediate-length allele in C9pos patients would modulate the age at onset or survival. Five C9pos patients had ≥17 repeat alleles (3 were FALS-A, and 5 were FALS-NP). Forty-two C9pos patients had 7–16 repeat alleles, 22 (52%) were FALS-A, and 31 (74%) FALS-NP. We did not find a statistically significant association between survival or age at onset and carriership of an intermediate-length allele. The median survival was 3.0 years in carriers of ≥17 repeat allele, 3.0 years in carriers of 7–16 repeat allele, and 2.0 years in carriers of 2–6 repeat allele (Kruskal-Wallis test: H = 0.657, p = 0.719). The mean age at onset was 50.8 years in carriers of ≥17 repeat allele, 56.5 years in carriers of 7–16 repeat allele, and 57.0 years in carriers of 2–6 repeat allele (1-way analysis of variance F = 1.39; p = 0.25).
Discussion
We describe the major genetic variant frequencies, familiality, and clinical features of a large cohort of patients with ALS with the C9orf72 hexanucleotide repeat expansion collected within a single country. The frequency of the C9orf72 repeat expansion was 31% in the whole cohort, 48%–58% among FALS families, and 17%–23% in SALS depending on the FALS criteria used. Survival was shortest in bulbar C9pos and longest in limb-onset Unk patients.
The 2 most common variants (C9orf72 and SOD1 p.D91A) were found in 40% of the 815 patients; 31% were C9pos, and 9% were SOD1 p.D91A homozygous. These data suggest an exceptional enrichment of these 2 variants in Finland. However, it should be noted that these percentages do not represent the true population rate because of possible referral bias, which usually increases the proportion of FALS. It has been reported that hospital-based studies have more SOD1 but fewer C9orf72 variants in FALS than population-based studies.4 Also, referral bias of unusually prolonged clinical course is possible, which may increase the proportion of SOD1 p.D91A. Although the percentages probably have an upward bias compared with the genuine population-based frequencies, these referral biases cannot be the sole cause for the high variant frequencies. When we excluded patients from outside referrals (which may have most bias), the frequencies of C9pos and SOD1 p.D91A patients were 30.3% and 5.5%, respectively. A significant increase of the SOD1 p.D91A (from 5.5% to 18.5%, eFigure 1, links.lww.com/NXG/A517) but not of C9pos patients was observed in outside referrals. This is expected given the high carrier frequency of SOD1p.D91A in Northern Finland. In systematic comparisons of worldwide studies (excluding isolates in the Western Pacific), Finland has had the highest17 or second highest18 age-adjusted incidence of ALS in the world. We conclude that the high incidence of ALS is contributed by the enrichment of the C9orf72 expansion and, to a lesser extent, the SOD1 p.D91A.
An explanation for the high frequency of the C9orf72 and SOD1 variants as well as the high incidence of ALS in Finland could be the Finnish population structure, which is featured with genetic isolation and genetic bottlenecks resulting in geographically clustered founder populations.35 This distinctive history has led to an enrichment of rare, mainly recessive Mendelian diseases among the population, collectively known as the Finnish disease heritage.36 The enrichment of certain variants can also be seen in adult-onset autosomal dominant neurologic disorders. For example, adult-onset spinal muscular atrophies are caused mainly by 2 founder variants in Finland: the X-linked Kennedy disease and SMA Jokela type by CHCHD10 variant.20,21 Enrichment of certain ALS variants has also been reported in Sardinia, another population with genetic founder effect, where 41% of the 375 studied patients with ALS had variants (in decreasing order) in TARDBP, C9orf72, SOD1, or MATR3 genes.37
Our FALS-A definition follows the traditional dichotomy defining a case FALS if there are 2 or more ALS cases in first- or second-degree relatives. At the beginning of our study (1993), there was some evidence about the link between ALS and FTD, but knowledge of other endophenotypes was limited. The information obtained in this study comprised of interviews and document reviews rather than direct examinations of relatives. We conducted the whole study uniformly and used the same information-gathering methods throughout. Today the somewhat anachronistic definition of FALS can be questioned in many ways, and the knowledge of the various endophenotypes has changed the picture. Our broader FALS-NP category included neuropsychiatric variables, and this resulted as a significant change from FALS-A (25%) to FALS-NP (45%). An Irish population-based study38 found that inclusion of the presence of neuropsychiatric endophenotypes within kindreds increased the FALS incidence rate to 30%. Our study also resulted in a slight change in the proportions of SALS/FALS in C9pos patients. The sensitivity to capture all these endophenotypes by interview is much more difficult than an established ALS diagnosis in a relative. Hence, we may have underestimated the amount of patients with FALS-NP.
A recent review39 on the prevalence of SOD1 and C9orf72 in 22 countries (Finland not included) suggested that the majority of patients with ALS with these variants may be found within the SALS group. Our results parallel this, and the high rate of C9pos among patients with SALS in Finland is interesting. Table 4 shows C9pos frequencies in patients with FALS and SALS from different countries and suggests that the Finnish population is an outlier in the frequency of the C9pos SALS. Several interpretations for this finding should be considered. First, the studies differ in FALS definition, case ascertainment (population based vs second or tertiary clinic based), and by including or excluding other variants. Not all studies report the version of El Escorial criteria used. Also, life expectancy and different family sizes among the countries may have influenced the recognition of FALS. Second, we might have misclassified some cases as SALS due to missed recognition of endophenotypes among relatives. On the other hand, we were able to monitor cryptic relatedness between patients using the GWAS data, which increased the sensitivity to detect patients with FALS-A. Third, the penetrance of the C9orf72 repeat expansion could be reduced in Finland, which would imply unknown protective factors in family members of the C9pos patients with SALS. This view is supported by the observed expansion carrier frequency 0.19% in the older Finnish population without ALS or FTD diagnosis; the expansion carriers were aged 68–79 years.33 Fourth, frequent de novo mutations could be 1 contributing factor. The frequency of the C9orf72 hexanucleotide repeat intermediate-length alleles of ≥20 repeats is about 2 times higher in Finland than in other European countries.30 Some of the ≥20 repeat alleles may represent unstable premutation alleles that could generate expansions. A larger pool of premutation alleles could partially explain the more significant proportion of C9pos SALS in Finland. Large intermediate-length alleles as the source of expansion have been previously shown in the Huntington disease CAG repeats.46,47
C9pos Patients With ALS in Different Cohorts of FALS and SALS
Several factors modified the age at onset of ALS in our data. Limb onset was the most decisive factor associated with earlier onset in the Unk group; the site of onset had a much smaller effect in the C9pos group (eTable 1, links.lww.com/NXG/A517). The C9pos patients overall had 3 years earlier onset than the Unk patients, which is in line with most previous reports.9,–,11,13 Our results also indicate that the survival of C9pos was significantly shorter than in Unk, and corresponding results have been reported in previous studies but occasionally with a broader age range.12,–,14 We did not observe an excess of bulbar onset in our C9pos group. This agrees with many studies,10,11,13,14 but bulbar-onset phenotype has dominated in others.8,9,16 Logistic regression analysis revealed that it is likely for C9pos patients to have relatives with ALS and an earlier age at onset and shorter survival than Unk patients. These findings confirm previous results reported in a large European population-based cohort.13
Although concomitant FTD indicates the existence of the C9orf72 expansion, this is not absolute. In our study, 70% of the patients with ALS-FTD were C9pos, divided into 64% familial and 36% sporadic patients (Table 1). This partly corresponds to the results of a study that combined 5 European populations15 and reported C9pos frequency in 72% C9pos patients with familial ALS-FTD and 17% in C9pos patients with sporadic ALS-FTD.
Risk factors for shorter survival in a Cox regression model including the total cohort indicated that the C9pos genotype, bulbar onset, and higher age at onset shortened survival, which is in agreement with previous data.48 The hazard ratios were in the range of 1.5–2, which represent relatively small effect sizes. A small effect size of a hazard ratio has been proposed to be in the range of >1.3, a medium effect size of >1.9, and a high effect size >2.8.49 Most studies report hazard ratios that are small to medium, which may explain why risk profiles have sometimes been inconsistent in different studies.
The MST is often used as a point estimate in comparing survival. The AUC of a survival curve is an intuitive measure of survival and allows direct comparison between groups. The analysis of MST revealed a clear pattern of how the age at onset affects the survival in both C9pos and Unk groups, with earlier age providing a more favorable survival, and this is consistent with a recent systematic meta-analysis of C9orf72-linked disease survival and prognosis.48 Another finding is the monotonic survival pattern in the bulbar-onset groups of both C9pos and Unk. The limb-onset C9pos group had an almost equally poor prognosis. In contrast, limb-onset Unk patients lived substantially longer (Figure 3). It has been suggested50 that the reduced survival in the C9orf72 expansion carriers is accountable on male sex, and especially on the limb-onset male patients, but this intriguing observation was not confirmed in a recent meta-analysis,48 in a population-based study51 or in our study. In our study, males tended to survive longer if they had limb onset and shorter if they had bulbar onset. There are many reasons for divergent results which are probably due to complex interactions between genes, environment, and lifestyle. Modifiable causal relationships like alcohol use and smoking have been shown to link to genetically determined ALS, primarily to C9orf72 noncarriers.52
Our study has several strengths. The cohort is large and originates from a relatively homogeneous population. As a result, we described a relatively uniform clinical picture of C9pos ALS in a Nordic population. The patients were traced, and their survival and course of the disease could be followed reliably due to the unique individual id-code used in Finland. In addition, GWAS data helped to detect cryptic relatedness between patients. The main limitation is that this is not a population-based study. Another limitation associates with the context of FALS. Our FALS-A definition likewise represents the traditional clinical situation, where ALS family history is considered either positive or negative, but the expanded FALS-NP is far from complete as well.53
The confirmation of the uniform clinical outcome of C9orf72 expansion carriers facilitates the design and result interpretations of trials using symptomatic and neuroprotective therapies. The better perception of C9orf72 characteristics also helps the clinician to estimate the prognosis and treatment challenges of a single patient. The connection with neuropsychiatric endophenotypes expands the consequences of the expansion. Accordingly, there is a need to rethink the concepts of sporadic and familial ALS.
Study Funding
This study was funded by The Sigrid Juselius Foundation, Helsinki University Hospital grants (TYH2018213 and TYH2019254), The Finnish Cultural Foundation, The Paulo Foundation, The Finnish Brain Foundation, The Finnish Medical Society Duodecim, ALS tuttu ry—The Finnish Association for Supporting ALS Research, and The Finnish Academy (318868). This work was supported in part by the Intramural Research Programs of the NIH, National Institute on Aging (Z01-AG000949-02).
Disclosure
H. Laaksovirta, J. Launes, and L. Jansson report no disclosures relevant to this manuscript. B.J. Traynor holds patents on the diagnostic and therapeutic implication of the C9orf72 repeat expansion. K. Kaivola reports no disclosures relevant to this manuscript. P.J. Tienari holds patents on the diagnostic and therapeutic implication of the C9orf72 repeat expansion. Go to Neurology.org/NG for full disclosures.
Acknowledgment
The authors thank all participants of this study.
Appendix Authors
Footnotes
Go to Neurology.org/NG for full disclosures. Funding information is provided at the end of the article.
The Article Processing Charge was funded by the funding body, University of Helsinki.
- Received October 4, 2021.
- Accepted in final form January 26, 2022.
- Copyright © 2022 The Author(s). Published by Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. on behalf of the American Academy of Neurology.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives License 4.0 (CC BY-NC-ND), which permits downloading and sharing the work provided it is properly cited. The work cannot be changed in any way or used commercially without permission from the journal.
References
Letters: Rapid online correspondence
REQUIREMENTS
If you are uploading a letter concerning an article:
You must have updated your disclosures within six months: http://submit.neurology.org
Your co-authors must send a completed Publishing Agreement Form to Neurology Staff (not necessary for the lead/corresponding author as the form below will suffice) before you upload your comment.
If you are responding to a comment that was written about an article you originally authored:
You (and co-authors) do not need to fill out forms or check disclosures as author forms are still valid
and apply to letter.
Submission specifications:
- Submissions must be < 200 words with < 5 references. Reference 1 must be the article on which you are commenting.
- Submissions should not have more than 5 authors. (Exception: original author replies can include all original authors of the article)
- Submit only on articles published within 6 months of issue date.
- Do not be redundant. Read any comments already posted on the article prior to submission.
- Submitted comments are subject to editing and editor review prior to posting.